Misleading Web Addresses Anger CUSD Candidate, Critics

The URLs look like they're for one school board candidate or organization, but take visitors elsewhere.

Sneaky website addresses that purport to represent an anti-incumbent school board candidate and groups but instead lead to opponents' webpages are stirring controversy in the Capistrano Unified School District. 

One of the misleading URLs — www.bill-perkins.com — uses the name of a candidate for the Aliso Viejo board seat, but instead takes browsers to Perkins' rival, incumbent school board President Gary Pritchard.

Pritchard could not be reached for comment.

Other URLs hijack the names of people or organizations that have questioned Capo Unified policies. For example, www.dawnurbanek.com reroutes web surfers to the website of Trustee John Alpay, who is running for re-election in San Clemente. Likewise, a website purporting to represent Hold CUSD Accountable actually leads to Capistrano Unified Children First, which is often at odds with the first group.

There’s even a fake Patch URL that leads to Children First.

Alpay could not be reached for comment.

Children First’s President Fran Sdao said her group has nothing to do with the misleading re-directs.

“We have no control what individuals do on their own,” Sdao said. “There are rogue characters in every campaign."

She added: “We have been trying to stay above board for the past three years. We’re parents, not political operatives.”

The misleading websites were registered through GoDaddy.com. Children First’s recent financial forms show a $134.61 payment to that company, but Children First Treasurer Gail Benda said it was for re-registration of the group’s own website, www.capounifiedchildrenfirst.org/.

Perkins said he has contacted an attorney about the matter to get GoDaddy's subsidiary, Domains by Proxy, which shields the identity of domain holders, to reveal who owns the URL that includes his name.

“The only thing you have in this life that they can’t take away from you is your name,” he said.

Julie Collier, president of Parents Advocate League, has also contacted a lawyer for what she believes is misappropriation of her name with www.juliecollier.com and the name of her nonprofit organization, www.parentsadvocateleague.com, which doesn’t endorse anyone for CUSD trustee.

“At the very best, it’s a childish, immature prank that you wouldn’t expect from adults,” said Collier’s lawyer, Wayne Tate, who is also representing his organization, Hold CUSD Accountable, in its efforts to combat yet another redirecting URL, www.holdcusdaccountable.com.

“More ominously, it could have substantial legal consequences,” Tate said.

Urbanek fired off a letter to GoDaddy on Monday morning, copying the missive to all CUSD trustees, Superintendent Joe Farley and the Orange County district attorney’s office.

A vocal critic of the district, Urbanek also sent an email to her supporters:

“I want to make you aware that the Domain name DAWNURBANEK.COM is being redirected to the website for Trustee John Alpay for the purpose of deceiving parents into believing that I support John Alpay for Trustee. I DO NOT SUPPORT JOHN ALPAY,” she wrote.

The state Fair Political Practices Commission said misleading website addresses don't fall under its purview.

A GoDaddy spokeswoman said such matters are "something we've dealt with in the past," but declined to comment further.

Corrine K October 17, 2012 at 03:58 PM
So the complaint is that he (Alpay) wants the pay to go back to where it originally was. So, 7 trustees x $325 = $2,450 each month, right?
Corrine K October 17, 2012 at 04:03 PM
CUSD Children First actually makes an important point. "Julie Collier, Dawn Urbanek and Bill Perkins? They weren't around in 2010." Bill Perkins is the latest Johnny Come Lately to try and run for an office with no experience and no expertise. Just a desire to be elected to something...anything.
Dadof2 October 17, 2012 at 04:27 PM
Whats even better than that, was 1 month ago John Alpay tried to get the board to vote on reducing their pay to 0. He added this gem to the agenda on a Friday afternoon, thinking nobody would get word of it and he could look like a hero. Just happened to coincide with a new election, and a new campaign piece he could then vocalize to the 20 teachers who support him. Everyone saw what he was trying to do. The board snickered, people called him out and I am sure he wasn't too happy about it. Which is it John? Double it? Reduce it? Take it to 0? Just depends whop is listening, and to what audience he is speaking. A politician in every sense of the word.
Penny Arévalo October 18, 2012 at 04:07 AM
Follow up story here: http://sanjuancapistrano.patch.com/articles/children-first-volunteer-tied-to-misleading-website-addresses
PDub October 19, 2012 at 07:07 AM
Dont forget at that board meeting when the pay was reduced by $50, there was already a motion on the floor by another trustee, to which Alpay ignored, and offered his motion which carried, all so he could get his name attached to the reduction in board pay just before election time...and when parents had the floor and spoke about his continued waste of board/taxpayers time...he referred to them as ones creating a "political circus".....seriously.....thats the kind of tact he has...not that he was going to get any votes from the group of SC parents in attendance anyway....


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »